VOICE: Audio feedback

Yes, there were a few minor technical hitches to overcome and I felt that I needed to know a little more about what I was preparing to do. Oh, how my pattern of having an idea, following it with investigation, preparation and application is so ingrained! OK, anyway, I found some ‘How to’ advice and a small number of positive evaluations so yes, I decided to go for it….audio feedback on student assessments.

I appreciate it’s been around for a while; however, the synergy of having head space, the technology, opportunity and a supportive workplace culture just hasn’t happened before. In all honesty, it doesn’t sound like a big deal, it wasn’t. Comment template prepared, equipment testing 123….testing 123….voice lowered and speech s…l…o…w…e…d… down I recorded 3 minutes of comments. I re-recorded and re-recorded following coughs, hesitations and deviations until; finally I reached a point where I had a complete recording. When I played it back I was ‘blown away’ not in the sense of Stephen Fry reading Harry Potter or anything Morgan Freeman says nor Richard Burton reading Under Milk Wood.  But it was the sense of humanity, ‘being there’, ‘being with’ the student continuing the rhythm of dialogue which fills our teaching and learning spaces.  Once student assessments are submitted the conversations which helped develop shared meanings and understandings, the dialogic space becomes charged with  academic discourse and processes which engender student powerlessness.

I struggle with the current lens on feedback as a ‘gap’ that requires closing or bridging. Whilst we use this frame of reference to formulate research, strategies and techniques we are constantly re-constructing the gap.  I wonder if Weick’s process of ‘sensemaking’ might help us understand the issue when he says ‘solutions seldom alter the dynamics of the process so problems keep showing up’. Let’s look at the dynamics of the teaching, learning space around student assessments. Let’s ask ourselves if we are ready to let students reclaim their writing.

The last word goes to the students, well almost, who said that they found audio feedback motivating and would like more. Am I using audio feedback again? You betcha!

Weick K.E. 1995 Sensemaking in Organizations. London. Sage

Teachers are sharing their ideas with teachers at Teachmeet Oldham – 6 May 2014 at University Campus Oldham



4 thoughts on “VOICE: Audio feedback

    • Hi Alison
      Thank you for your comment and I really appreciate the programme link.

      I just love the way the voice was described as carrying the ‘…essence of the person…the way someone speaks is of the person and in your mind it animates the person…’ and how the ‘…nuances of the voice….’ are very important.

      I’m also mindful of the discussion around ‘… losing our social nerve to have difficult/uncomfortable conversations…’ and wonder if audio feedback might open a conversation which for some students written feedback would not.

      I also caught a comment that ‘…the voice enhances experience…’ and this is surely what feedback needs right now, a little bit of enhancement.

      I’ll definitely listen to it again!

  1. […] might like to have a look at my previous blogs about voice and valuing individual student stories in the […]

  2. […] always given a lot of feedback as I see it as a way of continuing to engage with a student. I’ve written previously about my use of audio feedback and how it won me over. Still I dream of doing better. I dream of having the student sat beside me as I read their writing, […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s